Products are selected by our editors, we may earn commission from links on this page.
Halloween is such a great holiday, but it’s not the easiest holiday to dress for when you’re a modest dresser. You don’t want to show your shoulders, you don’t want to wear a tiny skirt, you don’t want to show cleavage, but you still want to look cool and participate in the holiday! Fortunately, we’ve rounded up the best modest Halloween costumes on Amazon. We’ve chosen costumes that offer you the coverage you’re looking for without compromising on the quality. You’ll love these costumes and you’ll enjoy feeling comfortable and covered all throughout the evening.
If you want a costume that covers you, but still feels comfortable and flowy, you want this Cleopatra costume. It’s comfortable, true to size, and made with a nice fabric that looks great. The costume is also super affordable, making it a fantastic choice for budget-conscious shoppers. You’ll love how nice you look and how comfortable you feel.
This fun mask and shirt combo is a fun and easy-to-wear option for those who want a modest Halloween costume. The shirt fits well, is comfortable, and is perfect for casual or work settings. This costume is a super easy choice if you want something grab-and-go. Turn yourself into the best crimefighting assistant with this kit.
This Jasmine costume is a beautiful and comfortable option if you want something cool but modest. The great quality and fit make it a wonderful choice, and the design is both accurate and eye-catching. The only thing uncovered is your shoulders, and those are just a little pop. No need to worry about exposing your midriff!
This kit is a really fantastic choice for those looking for a simple and cute Halloween or cosplay costume. The soft fabric and accurate colors make it a pleasure to wear, while the inflatable tail and wired ears add a fun touch. You can wear this set with your favorite pair of pants! It’s a great way to customize your costume experience.
This shawl is a beautiful and easy-to-wear accessory for Halloween or any dress-up event. The bright and colorful fabric brings a touch of whimsy, and the neck scrunchie and finger loops make it simple to put on. You don’t have to worry about what you wear with this shawl because anything would look cute! It’s a super simple modest option.
You can’t go wrong with a Sally costume! This one is a great option for fans of the movie. The costume fits well and includes a tie around the waist for a better fit. This costume is perfect for Halloween or themed parties, making it a worthwhile purchase. You get full coverage with this costume with no effort.
Embrace the Frozen vibes with this Anna costume. It’s a great choice for anyone looking for a modest Halloween costume. The design is accurate and visually appealing, making it perfect for fans of the character. The fabric is comfortable and warm, ideal for cooler weather. Overall, it’s a solid option for those wanting to look fabulous this Halloween.
This costume is so fun! It’s cute and comfortable, with light and breathable material that makes it easy to wear for extended periods. It also comes with a hat and tights, adding value to your purchase. This costume is a fantastic choice for Halloween or any costume event. You’ll love how covered you feel and how fun it looks.
Bring out your inner Jedi with this great costume! It’s a great pick for Star Wars fans seeking a modest Halloween costume. The design is accurate and recognizable, making it a hit at both Halloween parties and ComicCon events. The costume offers a comfortable fit and is made from good quality material.
This Alice in Wonderland costume is a great choice if you’re looking for a modest Halloween costume. It’s well-made, fits well, and offers a classic, sturdy design that stands out from typical costume dresses. With many positive reviews praising its quality and fit, it’s a reliable option for those aiming for a classic Alice in Wonderland look. The material is thicker than expected, ensuring it feels more like a real dress rather than a flimsy costume.
11. Hippie Costume
Bring it back to the 70s with this costume! It’s a fun and comfortable option for Halloween or any themed event. It fits well, includes matching accessories, and is ideal for layering in colder weather. If you’re looking for a 70s-themed outfit that stands out and is comfortable to wear, this is a solid choice. You can wear this outfit for any dress up event!
This flapper dress is one of our favorites. It’s a standout choice for a 1920s themed event or costume party. It features high-quality material and beautiful beading, making it both comfortable and stylish. This dress is perfect for anyone looking to capture the spirit of the Roaring Twenties with elegance and comfort.
If you want to really embrace modesty, this costume is definitely the way to do it! It includes a complete set with a habit and accessories, making it perfect for themed parties and cosplay events. Many users have praised its comfort, although some suggest ordering a size up for a better fit. Overall, it offers good value for the price and is sure to be a hit at any event.
Bippity boppity boo! This costume stands out for its high-quality design and materials. It fits well and is perfect for Disney-themed events, ensuring you look the part. Users have found the sizing to be accurate, making it a reliable choice for a magical and memorable costume.
15. Belle Costume
You’re going to love how flattering this modest costume it! It’s a wonderful option for fans of Beauty and the Beast. It accurately captures Belle’s look and comes with a bow and apron for added authenticity. It’s a bit on the pricey side, but it’s totally worth it! It’s a great pick for those who want to bring a classic Disney character to life.
16. Lab Coat
This lab coat is the perfect option for a quick and easy costume. Made from a high-quality cotton blend, it ensures durability and breathability. The ergonomic fit allows for easy movement, making it ideal for various professions. Plus, its machine-washable feature offers hassle-free cleaning. Whether for work or a modest Halloween costume, this lab coat is a great choice for maintaining a professional and trustworthy look.
This costume is almost Belle, but not quite! It’s a beautiful choice for anyone wanting to embody a fairytale princess. Its design is eye-catching and perfect for Halloween or themed events. Be prepared for some glitter, but overall, this dress offers a wonderful way to enjoy a modest Halloween costume.
This costume set is a fun and vibrant option for anyone looking to dress up for a party. It includes all the necessary accessories to complete the look, ensuring you stand out. The variety of sizes helps provide a comfortable fit, although some adjustments might be needed. Overall, it’s a great choice for a modest Halloween costume with a retro flair.
Anna might be the most relatable princess of all time. This costume is a wonderful choice for those wanting to transform into Anna from Frozen. The detailed design and rich colors make it a standout piece. It’s comfortable and allows for easy movement, making it perfect for events and parties.
You’re not in Kansas anymore! This costume offers a charming and high-quality option for Halloween. Its comfortable fit makes it suitable for all-day wear, and the well-made fabric ensures durability. The dress’s adorable design is perfect for those looking to embody a classic character with a modest touch.
Go with something classic and easy. This costume is a beautiful and elegant choice for a modest Halloween costume. The dress offers good quality for its price and fits well. It’s perfect for medieval-themed events and parties. This one is a standout option for those seeking a modest and stylish look.
This beautiful costume offers a sophisticated and well-crafted option for those seeking a modest Halloween costume. The blend of velvet and stretchy pleather ensures comfort and quality, while the headpiece adds an elegant touch. This costume has received tons of praise for its overall appearance and comfort, making it a great choice for themed parties or Halloween events.
This onesie is a fun and cozy option for anyone looking for a modest Halloween costume. Its cute design and comfortable material make it perfect for colder weather, and it comes in various sizes to accommodate different body types. The overall comfort and look make it a delightful choice for themed events or lounging at home.
24. Nanny Costume
A spoonful of sugar makes this costume even better! It’s an excellent choice for those seeking an authentic and modest Halloween costume. The high-quality fabric ensures comfort throughout the day, and the included hat with a removable headband adds a secure fit. This costume has gotten tons of high praise for its overall quality and authenticity, making it a standout option for Halloween or themed events.
This Captain Marvel costume is a great choice for anyone looking to dress up as the iconic superhero. It fits well, especially if you size down, and offers good quality for the price. Embrace your Marvel dreams with this costume. Overall, it’s a solid pick for Halloween or any superhero-themed event.
This gorgeous dress is a stunning and comfortable option for any 1920s themed event. The beading and fringe add an authentic touch, making you look like you walked right out of the roaring 20s. You’ll love looking and feeling authentic with this costume. It’s elegant, it’s gorgeous, and it glimmers beautifully.
There’s a snake in my boot! It’s a fun and comfortable choice for any Toy Story fan. It fits well and looks adorable, making it ideal for Halloween or costume parties. You’re going to fall in love with this costume. You might just wear this costume every chance you get.
This costume is super fun and a great choice for a modest Halloween outfit. Its comfortable material and vibrant colors make it stand out. Overall, it’s a well-made and durable costume that captures the essence of Snow White perfectly, making it a hit at any Halloween party. This costume is super easy to put together – you just need the shoes!
This witchy costume is a must-have! It’s an elegant and comfortable option for Halloween. The sturdy material ensures it will last for several years, and the design is sure to make you feel beautiful. This costume is a classy alternative to the typical witch outfits, making it a standout choice for Halloween.
This set makes Halloween so much easier! It’s a fun and easy-to-wear costume that’s perfect for Halloween. Its affordable price and good quality make it a great value. Just be sure to order a size up as it runs small. With its bright colors and iconic design, this costume is a great choice for anyone looking to dress up as Wonder Woman.
Let it go and get into this costume! This is a stunning option for those looking for a modest Halloween costume that embodies the magic of Elsa. With its beautiful design and comfortable fit, it’s a hit for cosplay or themed parties. Whether for a Halloween party or a Frozen-themed event, this costume will surely impress.
Bring the circus home with you. It’s a fantastic choice for those looking for a unique and modest Halloween costume. The jacket is of good quality and true to size, making it easy to pair with other pieces for a complete look. Perfect for a circus-themed party or performance, this costume is sure to stand out.
You can be one of the best Disney characters ever without having to expose yourself. This costume is a great pick for anyone wanting a modest Halloween costume that captures the superhero spirit. The flattering fit and comfortable material make it perfect for long wear, whether at a party or event.
The Maleficent is a great pick for a modest Halloween costume. It fits well, especially for taller individuals, and the headpiece is a nice touch that covers the hair completely. The open armpits allow for better breathability, making it comfortable to wear for extended periods. Sometimes, villains make the best costumes!
This onesie is perfect for those looking for a comfortable and warm modest Halloween costume. It’s made from soft, thick material that keeps you cozy, and it fits well even with clothes underneath. Halloween night is often chilly, but you can stay toasty with this costume! You can also wear it anytime of the year once the big night is over.
Dress up as your favorite drink ever with this costume. It’s a fun and easy modest Halloween costume option. It’s lightweight and simple to wear, making it convenient for quick costume changes. The material is good quality and fits well for different body types. Just pull it on over your favorite, laid back outfit.
You can’t go wrong with a pumpkin costume! This costume is comfortable, even for pregnant women, and has a timeless jack-o-lantern design. It’s super flexible and super simple. Pair it with leggings or pants for added comfort and coverage.
This gorgeous shawl is an easy and eye-catching Halloween accessory. Its lightweight, colorful fabric makes it both comfortable and attractive. It’s great for casual costumes or office parties, this shawl is sure to draw compliments. You’re going to love styling this for every party and trick-or-treat event.
This gorgeous costume is a stylish and versatile choice for Halloween or other themed events. The costume fits well and is made from higher-quality materials than expected. This outfit is a great value for those looking to make a magical impression. It’s an easy way to look super cool without exposing yourself at all.